|
"Peachtree
Burning"
A
one-hour documentary depicting the history and tragedy of the Winecoff
Hotel.
(Click
on photos to enlarge)
Home
The
Hotel's Origins
Built
in 1913 by renowned architect, William Lee Stoddard, the Winecoff Hotel
was Atlanta's tallest and most luxurious hotel. Standing fifteen stories
tall with an open-air terrace dining room, coffee shop and lounge, the
hotel was strategically located in the heart of Atlanta's retail district.
According
to their stationery, the hotel was advertised as being absolutely fireproof,
even though it was designed without fire alarms, fire escapes or a sprinkler
system.
On
December 7, 1946, the hotel was filled to capacity with over two hundred
and eighty guests including shoppers, travelers, World War II soldiers
eager to rebuild their lives, and forty of Georgia's most promising high
school students who had come to attend a mock legislation. And even though
the five year anniversary of Pearl Harbor Day was somberly approaching,
Christmas was just around the corner and there was a sense of
hope and excitement in the winter air.
Around
three o'clock in the morning, the elevator operator, descending from the
top floor, noticed the smell of smoke around the fifth floor. Panicked,
she stumbled out of the elevator upon reaching the lobby and began screaming,
"Fire! Fire!" Unbeknownst to her, the fire had already completely
engulfed floors three, four and five. For employees of the hotel and the
guests who were awake, realization and reaction would come quickly. But
for the guests who were asleep, survival would come at a much higher price.
Before dawn, a total of one hundred and nineteen lives would be lost.
The
Tragedy of The Hotel's Design
One
of the most critical factors contributing to this staggering loss of life
was the design of the building itself. Based on "European" design,
the hotel was a perfect square with the stairwell and elevator shafts
running straight through the middle. Thin wooden doors leading to the
stairwells had been left open on several floors as well as many transoms
above guest rooms allowing smoke and flames to be pulled upward like a
giant chimney. When the only means of egress became impassable, guests
were forced to the windows of their rooms, where they were met with precious
few choices. Many fashioned sheet ropes, while others doused their rooms
and themselves with toilet and bath water. Others simply awaited their
fates in hopeless silence.
Firefighting
Efforts
By
the time fire trucks arrived, many guests were already on the verge of
jumping and many lept to their deaths moments before ladders reached their
windows. Fear had reached such a fevered pitch that panic-strickened guests
became desperate, and nothing short of a human rain shower ensued. Several
firefighters fell to their deaths or were injured after being knocked
off their ladders by falling bodies. Mothers
hurled their babies from windows only to follow them to their deaths.
Rescue
efforts were further hindered by the geographic location of the building.
The Mortgage Guarantee Building sat opposite the hotel with only about
six feet of alley between them. This prevented any kind of rescue from
the firetrucks. But perhaps the most unfortunate limitation came from
the trucks themselves. Back then, fire trucks were outfitted with ladders
that could only reach as high as the seventh floor.
Eighty
percent of the fatalities were guests who were staying above the eighth
floor and on the back side of the building. It
was reported that thirty-six people died from falling or jumping, thirty-two
burned and forty-one suffocated from smoke and fumes. Perhaps the most
tragic of these victims were the thirty teenage children who lost their
lives and the elderly Winecoffs, who had resided in the hotel since its
inception.
The
Investigation: Accident or Arson?
By
the time Mayor Hartsfield arrived at the location, nothing remained but
smoldering embers and the smell of burnt flesh. The brick exterior was
still intact, but the hollow shell of its inside
told a different and tragic story. According to a report filed by the
National Board of Underwriters, a partially burned mattress found in a
hallway on the third floor gave rise to the conclusion that a careless
and possibly intoxicated guest dropped a cigarette onto it, thus starting
the fire.
Pressured
by public outcry for culpability, and anxious to prove himself as "the
mayor who cares", Hartsfield invited fire experts from across the
country to conduct their own investigations. Many of these experts were
convinced that due to the massive devastation, the intensity of the fire's
heat and the speed at which it accelerated, a smoldering mattress could
not possibly have been the cause. Several arson theories emerged including
an illegal poker game on the third floor that spun out of control. But
the press and the public in general were more concerned about why an "absolutely
fireproof" hotel lacked fire escapes, a sprinkler system and fire
alarms and less concerned with theories of arson. They demanded answers
from the hotel's owners and operators.
Families
and Survivors File Suit
In
1948, the first of over one hundred and fifty lawsuits came to trial against
the Winecoff Hotel Company. The plaintiffs' lawyers hoped to prove that
the hotel owner and the hotel operators were negligent in not providing
adequate fire safety devices. The defendants' attorneys were charged with
proving arson, thereby absolving their clients of liability and relieving
their insurance companies of paying the huge claim. In the end, however,
no arson theory could be substantiated, and only the hotel operators,
not it's owner were found to be liable. Although the plaintiffs were awarded
over $3.5 million in damages, the hotel operators were only insured for
$350,000 and most of the families received less than $1,000 each.
The
Fire's Effect On Fire Safety Codes
Because
the building had a brick exterior, the owners were able, under certain
insurance provisions, to classify the hotel as "fireproof" even
though it was not fitted with fire escapes, fire sprinklers nor an alarm
system. Indeed, the exterior did not burn in the fire, but the contents
did. The furniture, carpet, hallways, wainscoting and painted walls were
highly flammable. Even the stairwells were constructed of wood and became
impassible when the fire chose this as its main route of destruction.
Up
until the time of the Winecoff fire, no national codes had been required
and decisions about fire safety were left to the discretion of local city
officials, . Mayor Hartsfield had once argued that Atlanta
property owners should be spared the hassle of retrofitting existing buildings
in order to bring them up to code due to the enormous expense involved.
He reasoned, "Why should we make it safe in Atlanta when Atlantans
going to other towns would be in the same danger?" His position was
quite popular with the property owners.
As
a result of the Winecoff disaster, many fire officials became enraged
and cried, "Never again!" It was determined that local officials
could not be relied upon to make responsible decisions about fire safety,
and national safety codes were established and strictly enforced. The
response to this tragedy was so intense that officials in several southern
cities ordered all existing buildings be retrofitted and brought up to
code within seven days or be shut down. It is a testament to the effectiveness
of these newly enforced codes that in this country there has never been
a hotel fire since in which so many lost their lives.
The
Winecoff After The Fire
In
April of 1951, the hotel reopened as the Peachtree on Peachtree Hotel,
complete with fire alarms and fire escapes. But competing hotels were
cropping up all around Atlanta's retail district and by 1967, with no
buyers in sight, the hotel was donated to the Georgia Baptist Convention
who used it as housing for the elderly. In 1981, the hotel was sold to
a real estate conglomerate and would pass through the hands of no less
a dozen more buyers over the next twenty five years. Each had high hopes
but no solid deal to resurrect the hotel ever materialized. Today, in
2005, the hotel remains an eyesore and a thorn in the side of a city whose
officials would have demolished it decades ago if it did not reside above
the city's railway system, preventing it from being imploded. To this
day, the building stands as a hollowed-out shell reminding us of the tragedy
that occurred there. The curse of the Winecoff Hotel solidly remains and
many local merchants claim that the building is haunted, having seen ghosts
puttering about on more than on occasion.
The Winecoff Hotel Fire of 1946 held the unenviable honor of being known
as the deadliest hotel fire in the world and maintained that title until
1971 when one hundred and sixty-two people lost their lives in a hotel
fire in Seoul, South Korea. The Winecoff remains, to this day, the worst
hotel fire in American history. The fate of this once glamorous and celebrated
hotel is unclear, but one thing is certain, it must never be forgotten.
|